Love in Transition
As Led Zeppelin's 'What Is and What Should Never Be' unfolds, it serves as a poignant reflection of the evolving nature of love in the late 1960s and early 1970s. Released on the band's second studio album, Led Zeppelin II, in 1969, the track stands out for its intricate lyrics and shifting musical dynamics, mirroring the complexities of romantic relationships during this transformative era.
The late '60s marked a significant cultural shift. The idealized notions of love that had dominated the previous decade began to crumble under the weight of social upheaval and the burgeoning sexual revolution. Zeppelin captures this duality in their lyrics, particularly in the way they oscillate between the ideal and the real. The line,
speaks to a desire for genuine connection amid the chaos."And if you want a piece of my heart, you’re gonna have to start from the start"
Contradictions and Confusion
Much like the relationships of the time, the song itself is marked by contradictions. Its fluid structure allows for moments of introspection and longing, punctuated by bursts of rock energy that reflect the tumult of the era. The notion of love as a complex interplay rather than a straightforward narrative aligns with the realities many faced. The line
reveals the tension between personal aspirations and the expectations of love."But all I see is what I should never be"
In a broader context, the 1970s were characterized by a rejection of traditional values around love and relationships. The rise of counterculture movements challenged the status quo, prompting individuals to seek authenticity over societal approval. Zeppelin’s music, particularly in this track, embodies that struggle, reflecting a generation caught between romantic idealism and harsh realities.
Musical Influences
The blues roots of Zeppelin are also present in this song, drawing from a rich tradition of emotional expression. The influence of artists like Memphis Minnie, whose song When the Levee Breaks would later be covered by Zeppelin on their fourth album, underscores the band's deep connection to the blues genre. This lineage of music provides a rawness that complements the lyrical exploration of love.
Led Zeppelin II was a commercial success, solidifying the band's status as rock legends with its heavy sound and innovative production.
Love as a Reflection of Self
The track’s introspective nature also speaks to the self-awareness that became crucial in 1970s love narratives. As individuals began to recognize the importance of self-identity within relationships, Zeppelin's lyrics resonate powerfully. The acknowledgment that love is as much about personal growth as it is about connection is evident in lines like
which blend vulnerability with a desire to shield loved ones from pain."You know that I can’t stand to see you cry"
Ultimately, 'What Is and What Should Never Be' acts as a mirror to the societal shifts surrounding love during the 1970s. It reflects a growing recognition that love is not merely a romantic ideal but a complex interplay of emotions, desires, and personal growth. The song's legacy continues to influence how we understand relationships today, reminding us that love is often a journey filled with contradictions.