The Evolution of a Classic
Released in 1969, 'What Is and What Should Never Be' emerged from the creative furnace of Led Zeppelin II. This track, masterfully crafted by the band, is emblematic of their ability to blend hard rock with more intricate, reflective songwriting. The 1990 remaster brought renewed attention to its complex structure and lyrical depth, showcasing the band's evolution since their debut.
Behind the Scenes
The song's genesis can be traced back to a time when the band was navigating the pressures of fame following their explosive debut. Producer Jimmy Page, who had a hand in shaping the band's sound, was keen to explore different musical landscapes. This ambition is evident in the song's shifting dynamics, from the soft, almost ethereal verses to the explosive choruses.
Did you know? The song's unusual time signature and tempo changes were groundbreaking for rock music at the time.
Lyricism and Themes
The lyrics of 'What Is and What Should Never Be' are a reflection on longing and uncertainty. The line,
subtly conveys the push and pull in relationships, a theme that resonates throughout the album. It’s a stark contrast to the aggressive tones found in tracks like 'Whole Lotta Love,' demonstrating the band's range."And if you want a drink of water, you're gonna have to wait for me"
Musical Composition
Musically, the song features a blend of acoustic and electric instrumentation, a hallmark of Zeppelin's style. The interplay between Robert Plant’s haunting vocals and Jimmy Page’s intricate guitar work creates a sonic tension that mirrors the lyrical content. The 1990 remaster enhanced these elements, bringing clarity to the nuances that had been somewhat lost in the original mix.
A Lasting Legacy
As the years have passed, 'What Is and What Should Never Be' has cemented its place in rock history. The track's ability to traverse genres—melding rock with folk influences—has inspired countless musicians. Its remastering in 1990 served as a reminder of Led Zeppelin's innovative spirit and the timelessness of their music.
Interesting fact: The song was performed live only a handful of times during the band’s career, making each rendition a unique experience.
The 1990 Remaster
The 1990 remaster of Led Zeppelin II, including this track, was part of a larger effort to reintroduce the band's catalog to a new generation. With improved sound quality and a fresh perspective, it highlighted the nuances that fans had come to appreciate. This remaster has since become a definitive listening experience for both new listeners and long-time fans, reminding us of the groundbreaking work the band accomplished in their early years.
Conclusion
'What Is and What Should Never Be' remains a testament to Led Zeppelin's artistry. It encapsulates both the struggle of personal relationships and the band's innovative approach to rock music. The song has not only endured the test of time but has also continued to evolve through its various interpretations and remasterings.